Skip to main content

Improvements to updates for Foxfooders

We've been providing on-device updates (that is to say: no flashing required) to users in the Foxfood program for nearly 6 months now. These updates are intended for users who are officially part of the Foxfooding program, but the way our update system works means that anyone who puts themselves on the right update channel can receive them. This makes things tough for us, because we'd like to be able to provide official Foxfooders with some extra bits and we can't do that while these populations are on the same update channel. Thanks to work that Rob Wood and Alexandre Lissy are doing, we'll soon be able to resolve this and get Foxfooders the bits they need to do the best possible testing.

To make this possible, we've implemented a short term solution that lets us only serve updates to official Foxfooders. When landed, they will send a hashed version of their IMEI as part of their update request. A list of the acceptable IMEI hashes will be maintained in Balrog (the update server), which lets us only serve an update if the incoming one matches one of the whitelisted ones.

To really make this work we need to detangle the current "dogfood" update channel. As I mentioned, it's currently being used in two distinct populations of users: those are part of the official program, and those who aren't. In order to support both populations of users we'll be splitting the "dogfood" update channel into two:

  1. The new "foxfood" channel will be for users who are officially part of the Foxfooding program. Users on this channel will be part of the IMEI whitelist, and could receive FOTA or OTA updates.
  2. The "dogfood" channel will continue to serve serve OTA updates to anyone who puts themself on it.

To transition, we will be asking folks who are officially part of the Foxfooding program to flash with a new image that switches them to the "foxfood" update channel. When this is ready to go, it will be announced and communicated appropriately.

Big thanks to everyone who was involved in this effort, particularly Rob Wood, who implemented the new whitelisting feature in Balrog, and Alexandre Lissy and Jean Gong, who went through multiple rounds of back and forth before we settled on this solution.

It's worth noting that this solution isn't ideal: sending IMEIs (even hashed versions) isn't something we prefer to do for both reasons of user privacy and protection of the bits. In the longer term, we'd like to look at a solution that wouldn't require IMEIs to be sent to us. This could come in the form of embedding or asking for credentials, and using those to access the updates. This type of solution would enhance user privacy and make it harder to get around the protections by brute forcing.

Going Faster with Balrog

Go Faster is a broad initiative at Mozilla that is focused on shipping things to users much faster than the current 6 week cycle. One important part of this project is having a mechanism to make Firefox aware of updates they need or may want to download. This is nothing entirely new of course - we've been shipping updates to users since Firefox 1.5 - but with Go Faster we will be updating bits and pieces of Firefox at a time rather than always updating the entire install. In this post I'm going to outline these new types of updates that we've identified, and talk about how things will work in the Glorious Future.

A Primer on Updates

Firefox updates work on a "pull" system, meaning Firefox regularly queries the update server (Balrog) to ask if there's an update available. For example, my Firefox is currently polling for updates by making a GET request to this URL:

https://aus5.mozilla.org/update/3/Firefox/41.0/20150915150946/Linux_x86_64-gcc3/en-GB/beta/default/default/default/update.xml

All of the information in that URL is mapped against a set rules in Balrog, and eventually points to a single release. If that release is newer than the incoming one (based on the incoming version and buildid), Balrog returns the information necessary for the client to update to it:

<updates>
    <update type="minor" displayVersion="41.0" appVersion="41.0" platformVersion="41.0" buildID="20150917150946" detailsURL="https://www.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/41.0/releasenotes/">
        <patch type="complete" URL="http://download.mozilla.org/?product=firefox-41.0build3-complete&os=linux64&lang=en-GB" hashFunction="sha512" hashValue="ea0757069363287f67659d8b7d42e0ac6c74a12ce8bd3c7d3e9ad018d03cd6f4640529c270ed2b3f3e75b11320e3a282ad9476bd93b0f501a22d1d9cb8884961" size="48982398"/>
    </update>
</updates>

It's important to note that Balrog only contains metadata about the update. The actual payloads of the updates are hosted on CDN networks.

New Types of Updates

We've identified three different new types of updates that we'll be implementing as part of Go Faster. They are:

  • System Addons: These are core (aka required) parts of Firefox that happen to be implemented as Addons.
  • Security Policy: This is a medium sized piece of JSON that instructs NSS about special security policies to enforce for various websites.
  • Optional Features: These are optional parts of Firefox that may be implemented as Addons or other means.

Each one of these will be implemented as an additional update request to Balrog (we may collapse these into a single request later). Eg, Firefox will look for new System Addons by making a GET request to an URL such as:

https://aus5.mozilla.org/update/3/SystemAddons/41.0/20150915150946/Linux_x86_64-gcc3/en-GB/beta/default/default/default/update.xml

The responses will vary a bit depending on the type of update. More on that below.

System Addons

Seeing as Firefox can't function without them, System Addons may seem like a contradiction at first. The advantages are quite clear though: with them, we can ship updates to self contained pieces of Firefox at a substantionally faster rate. Shipping an update to all of Firefox takes nearly 24 hours (when we're moving as fast as we can); shipping an update to a System Addon could take as little as minutes.

Although they are implemented as Addons, we can't simply ship them through the AMO. Because Firefox cannot function without them we must ship them in the installers and full updates that happen every 6 weeks. This has the nice side effect of minimizing dependency problems -- we won't run into a case where Firefox updates but System Addons don't, which could cause incompatibilities. In between the 6 week cycles Firefox will poll Balrog for updates to System Addons and apply them as they become available. This graph may show this more clearly:



As you can see, Firefox 50.0 can be assumed to have any of Fizz 1.0, 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, or 2.0, while Firefox 51.0 is known to only have Fizz 2.0 (but may receive newer versions later).

When Firefox pings Balrog for System Addon updates, the response will look something like this:

<updates>
    <addons>
        <addon id="fizz@mozilla.org" URL="http://download.cdn.mozilla.net/fizz-1.1.xpi" hashFunction="sha512" hashValue="abcdef123456" version="1.1"/>
        <addon id="pop@mozilla.org" URL="http://download.cdn.mozilla.net/pop-2.5.xpi" hashFunction="sha512" hashValue="abcdef123456" version="2.5"/>
        <addon id="bam@mozilla.org" URL="http://download.cdn.mozilla.net/bam-3.4.xpi" hashFunction="sha512" hashValue="abcdef123456" version="3.4"/>
    </addons>
</updates>

Firefox will compare the list against its currently installed versions and update anything that's out of date. The exact details on where System Addons will live on disk are still being ironed out.

Security Policy

Every version of Firefox ships with the most up-to-date set of security policies that were available when it was built. However, these policies are updated more frequently than we ship, and it's crucial that we keep them up to date to keep our users safe. As with System Addons, Firefox will regularly ping Balrog to check for updated security policies. When one is found, Firefox downloads it from Kinto, which will serve it an incremental update to its security policies. The details of this process have been outlined in much more detail by the Cloud Services team.

The Balrog response for these updates is extremely simple, and simply contains a version that Firefox passes along to Kinto:

<updates>
    <settings>
        <setting id="security" lastModified="129386427328"/>
    </settings>
</updates>

Optional Features

These are parts of Firefox that are not core to the browser, but may be useful to subsets of users. For example: We currently ship a ton of hyphenation dictionaries as part of Firefox for Android. These are locale-specific, so only one ever gets used for each user. We can also distribute opt-in features that not everyone wants or needs, eg: Developer Tools may be a good candidate (there are no plans to do so at this time though).

Optional features may also be implemented in various ways. Hyphenation dictionaries are simple zip files, while something like Developer Tools would likely be an Addon. They will not be included in Firefox installers or update packages. Instead Firefox will regularly query Balrog to see what packages may be available to it. Some things may automatically install based on the user's environment (eg: hyphentation dictionaries for your locale), while other things may require opt-in (eg: optional features).

Balrog responses are not yet set in stone for these, but Kinto is likely to be involved, so the response may end up being similar to the one above for Security Policy updates.

Summary

While System Addons, Security Policy, and Optional Features overlap in some areas, each has its own unique combination of requirements. The chart below summarizes these:
Required? Shipped in Installer? Payload Type Payload Location
System Addons Yes Yes Addons CDN
Security Policy Yes Yes JSON Kinto
Optional Features No No Anything Kinto

Mozilla Software Release GPG Key Transition

Late last week we discovered the expiration of the GPG key that we use to sign Firefox, Fennec, and Thunderbird nightly builds and releases. We had been aware that this was coming up, but we unfortunately missed our deadline to renew it. This caused failures in many of our automated nightly builds, so it was quickly noticed and acted upon.

Our new GPG key is as follows, and available on keyservers such as gpg.mozilla.org and pgp.mit.edu:

pub   4096R/0x61B7B526D98F0353 2015-07-17
      Key fingerprint = 14F2 6682 D091 6CDD 81E3  7B6D 61B7 B526 D98F 0353
uid                            Mozilla Software Releases 
sub   4096R/0x1C69C4E55E9905DB 2015-07-17 [expires: 2017-07-16]

The new primary key is signed by many Mozillians, the old master key, as well as our OpSec team's GPG key. Nightlies and releases will now be signed with the subkey (0x1C69C4E55E9905DB), and a new one will be generated from the same primary key before this one expires. This means that you can validate Firefox releases with the primary public key in perpetuity.

We are investigating a few options to make sure key renewal happens without delay in the future.

Mozilla will stop producing automated builds of XULRunner after the 41.0 cycle

XULRunner is a runtime package that can be used to run XUL+XPCOM based applications. Automated builds of it have been produced alongside Firefox since 2006, but it has not been a supported or resourced product for many years. We've continued to produce automated builds of it because its build process also happens to build the Gecko SDK, which we do support and maintain. This will change soon, and we'll start building the Gecko SDK from Firefox instead (bug 672509). This work will land on mozilla-central during the 42.0 cycle, which means that when the 41.0 cycle ends (September 22, 2015), automated builds of XULRunner will cease.

If you are a consumer of the Gecko SDK this means very little to you -- we will continue to produce it with every Firefox release.

If you are a consumer of the XULRunner stub this means that you will no longer have a Mozilla produced version after 41.0. For folks in this group, you have two options:

  • Change your app to run through the stub provided by Firefox. Many apps will continue to work as before by simply replacing "xulrunner.exe application" with "firefox -app application.ini".
  • Build XULRunner yourself.

Translation: Eraserheads - Alapaap

Original Lyrics

Intro:

May isang umaga na tayo'y magsasama

Haya at halina sa alapaap

O, anong sarap, haa...

Verse 1:

Hanggang sa dulo ng mundo

Hanggang maubos ang ubo

Hanggang gumulong ang luha

Hanggang mahulog ang tala

Chorus 1:

Masdan mo ang aking mata

'Di mo ba nakikita

Ako ngayo'y lumilipad at nasa langit na

Gusto mo bang sumama?

Verse 2:

Hindi mo na kailangan ang magtago't mahiya

Hindi mo na kailangan humanap ng iba

Kalimutan lang muna ang lahat ng problema

Huminga ka ng malalim at tayo'y lalarga na

Handa na bang gumala

Adlib:

Pap-pa-rap... pap-pa-rap-pa...

La-la-la... oooh hoo hoo...

Verse 3:

Ang daming bawal sa mundo

Sinasakal nila tayo

Buksan ang puso at isipan

Paliparin ang kamalayan

Chorus 2:

Masdan mo ang aking mata

'Di mo ba nakikita

Ako ngayo'y lumilipad at nasa alapaap na

Gusto mo bang (repeat 7 times)

Gusto mo bang sumama

English Lyrics

Intro:

There will be a morning when we're together

We'll abandon everything and go to the clouds

O, how nice that will be...

Verse 1:

Until the end of the world

Until my cough is all gone

Until my tears are rolling

Until the sun falls

Chorus 1:

Look into my eyes

Can't see it?

I'm flying right now and in heaven

Do you want to join me?

Verse 2:

You don't need to hide and be shy

You don't need to search for someone else

Just forget all of your problems

You breathe deeply and we'll let loose now

Ready to go?

Adlib:

Pap-pa-rap... pap-pa-rap-pa...

La-la-la... oooh hoo hoo...

Verse 3:

There's so many restrictions in the world

It's strangling us

Open your heart and mind

Knowledge is flying(???)

Chorus 2:

Look into my eyes

Can't see it?

I'm flying right now and in the clouds

Do you want to (repeat 7 times)

Do you want to join me?

Translation: Parokya ni Edgar - Halaga

Original Lyrics

Umiiyak ka na naman

Langya talaga, wala ka bang ibang alam

Namumugtong mga mata

Kailan pa ba kaya ikaw magsasawa

Sa problema na iyong pinapasan

Hatid sa 'yo ng boyfriend mong hindi mo maintindihan

May kwento kang pandrama na naman

Parang pang TV na walang katapusan

Hanggang kailan ka bang ganyan

Hindi mo ba alam na walang pupuntahan

Ang pagtiyaga mo diyan sa boyfriend mong tanga

Na wala nang ginawa kundi ang paluhain ka

Chorus:

Sa libu-libong pagkakataon na tayo'y nagkasama

Iilang ulit pa lang kitang nakitang masaya

Naiinis akong isipin na ginaganyan ka niya

Siguro ay hindi niya lang alam ang iyong

Tunay na halaga

Hindi na dapat pag-usapan pa

Napapagod na rin ako sa aking kakasalita

Hindi ka rin naman nakikinig

Kahit sobrang pagod na ang aking bibig

Sa mga payo kung 'di mo pinapansin

Akala mo'y nakikinig 'di rin naman tatanggapin

Ayoko nang isipin pa

'Di ko alam ba't 'di mo makayanan na iwanan siya

Ang dami-dami naman diyang iba

'Wag kang mangangambang baka wala ka nang ibang makita

Na lalake na magmamahal sa 'yo

At hinding hindi niya sasayangin ang pag-ibig mo

(Repeat Chorus)

Minsan hindi ko maintindihan

Parang ang buhay natin ay napagti-tripan

Medyo malabo yata ang mundo

Binabasura ng iba ang siyang pinapangarap ko

(Repeat Chorus)

English Lyrics

You're crying so much

Damn, you don't know anything else

Your eyes are beaten down

When will you ever get tired of this?

The burden that you're carrying

Is being with boyfriend that you don't understand

Your story is so dramatic

It's like a TV show that never ends

How long will you stay like this?

Don't you know that there's no end in sight?

You have such patience for your stupid boyfriend

Who does nothing except make you cry

Chorus:

Even though we've hung out thousands of times

I've only seen you happy a few

I'm disgusted when I think about how he is with you

Maybe he just doesn't know

What really matters to you

We should stop talk anymore

I'm weary again from speaking

You're just not listening again

Even my mouth is getting tired now

If you wouldn't ignore my advice

You seem to listen but you don't accept it

I don't want to keep thinking about it

I don't know why you can't bear to leave him

When there's so many others out there

You shouldn't be afraid because you'll find another

Man who will love you

And he won't take your love for granted

(Repeat Chorus)

Sometimes I don't understand

It's like our lives are just full of bad luck

Maybe the world is just unpredictable

Others have thrown away my good dreams

(Repeat Chorus)

Buildbot &lt;-&gt; Taskcluster Bridge Now in Production

A few weeks ago I gave a brief overview of the Buildbot <->Taskcluster Bridge that we've been developing, and Selena provided some additional details about it yesterday. Today I'm happy to announce that it is ready to take on production work. As more and more jobs from our CI infrastructure move to Taskcluster, the Bridge will coordinate between them and jobs that must remain in Buildbot for the time being.

What's next?

The Bridge itself is feature complete until our requirements change (though there's a couple of minor bugs that would be nice to fix), but most of the Buildbot Schedulers still need to be replaced with Task Graphs. Some of this work will be done at the same time as porting specific build or test jobs to run natively in Taskcluster, but it doesn't have to be. I made a proof of concept on how to integrate selected Buildbot builds into the existing "taskcluster-graph" command and disable the Buildbot schedulers that it replaces. With a bit more work this could be extended to schedule all of the Buildbot builds for a branch, which would make porting specific jobs simpler. If you'd like to help out with this, let me know!